← Election Series · Down-ballot coverage · Arizona
Our call — see the breakdown
The race
Decided earlier — Casa Grande holds no November 3, 2026 election for mayor or council. The city states it plainly: "Casa Grande will not hold a General Election for Mayor or City Council this November as all four seats were decided in the Primary Election on July 21, 2026. In accordance with Arizona law and City Ordinance No. 3059, candidates receiving the required majority of votes cast for their respective offices are declared elected at the Primary Election." Mayor Lisa Navarro Fitzgibbons was re-elected; council seats went to Anthony Edwards (re-elected), Matt Herman (re-elected), and Billie Davis (elected). They are sworn in at the December 7, 2026 council meeting. Casa Grande's only November 3 local item is Proposition 407, the APS franchise agreement, covered in our measures coverage.
The official Pinal County primary results give the scale: Fitzgibbons, the sole mayoral candidate on the ballot, received 6,919 votes. For the three council seats — also with exactly three ballot candidates — Edwards received 5,908, Herman 5,509, and Davis 5,353.
The candidates
Lisa Navarro Fitzgibbons — mayor, re-elected. Fitzgibbons was the incumbent and the only candidate who filed for mayor; her current term ran 2025–2026 under Casa Grande's two-year mayoral cycle. She faced write-in votes only (150 recorded). No challenger tested her record in this cycle, and no campaign platform fight exists in the sourced record to price.
The council three — Edwards, Herman, Davis. Edwards and Herman were incumbents re-elected to seats they had held since 2023; Davis is the newcomer, taking the third seat (incumbent Robert Huddleston's seat was the one that turned over). Davis took the GoodParty.org pledge, per that listing. As with the mayor's race, the field was exactly as large as the number of seats, so no candidate was eliminated by voters.
Pros and cons
- Fitzgibbons — Pro: An incumbent mayor re-elected without a filed challenger in a growing city — no sourced scandal, recall, or organized opposition emerged in this pass. Con: An uncontested re-election is ratification, not examination; her record was never priced by an opponent, and this article found no contested claim about her tenure to verify or refute.
- Edwards / Herman — Pro: Incumbent continuity, re-elected on the same July ballot. Con: Same structural gap — no challenger, no campaign debate in the record.
- Davis — Pro: The one new voice on the dais, with a public people-first pledge on file. Con: No prior elected record in the sources worked.
OUR CALL
Our call: no November call — the race was decided July 21, 2026, and we record the outcome, not a pick. Fitzgibbons (mayor), Edwards, Herman, and Davis (council) are elected and take office December 7, 2026. On the record verified here — uncontested filings, official vote totals, and the city's own statement of the majority-at-primary rule — there is no affirmative contested record that would support a retroactive endorsement or a retroactive rejection, and we do not manufacture one. Casa Grande voters with a November decision still have one: Proposition 407.
For the complete Election 2026 breakdown — every race, claim by claim — see the full coverage on our website. Vote early. Research your candidates. Choose the best moderates, whatever their party — no extremism from either side. And encourage your friends and family to do the same. --- Sources
- City of Casa Grande (official city government page, October 6, 2026 post) — no November general election for mayor/council; all four seats decided July 21 under Arizona law and Ordinance No. 3059; winners named; December 7, 2026 swearing-in; Prop 407 is the November local item — https://www.findglocal.com/US/Casa-Grande/93089921359/City-of-Casa-Grande---Government
- Pinal County, Official Results, 2026 Primary Election (July 21, 2026), Summary Results Report — Fitzgibbons 6,919; Edwards 5,908; Herman 5,509; Davis 5,353 — https://public.destinyhosted.com/casagdocs/2026/CCREG/20260803_2810/10004_Exhibit_A_Summary_Results_Report.pdf
- GoodParty.org, Mayor in Casa Grande — sole candidate filed: Lisa Fitzgibbons; current term 2025–2026 — https://goodparty.org/elections/az/pinal-county/casa-grande/position/city-executive-mayor
- GoodParty.org, City Council in Casa Grande — three candidates for three seats: Billie Davis (pledge), Matthew Herman, Anthony Edwards — https://goodparty.org/elections/az/pinal-county/casa-grande/position/city-legislature
Result pending. No verified call (Associated Press or official) as of November 4, 2026. This page will be updated when the race is called or certified. The original article above is unchanged.
AI-assisted article — but the sources are human, and the facts are very real.