← Election Series · All senate races

Our verdict

LiberalMind endorses Don Tracy — as unproven, and on watch

Election Day is November 3. Dick Durbin's seat is open, and the raters say it stays Democratic. This is the whole race — the records, the platforms, and what the sources actually show. Read the research, and decide.

How Illinois got here

This Class 2 seat is open because Senator Dick Durbin is retiring; he announced in April 2025 that he would step down at the end of his term, and he is not on the ballot. The roster is confirmed from the Illinois State Board of Elections' list of active general-election candidates: Juliana Stratton, Democrat; Don Tracy, Republican; and Whitfield Harrington Jr., whose ballot designation is American Center Party — not Independent, as some listings say. One caution for readers of stale coverage: independent candidate Tyrone F. Muhammad was removed from the ballot by the State Board of Elections on July 14, 2026, and is not a candidate.

Stratton won the March 17, 2026 Democratic primary over two sitting U.S. representatives, Raja Krishnamoorthi and Robin Kelly — the lieutenant governor beat the congressional field outright. The raters are not close: Cook Solid D (Oct. 20), Inside Elections Solid D (Oct. 15), Sabato's Crystal Ball and DDHQ Safe D. Polling agrees: ActiVote (Sept. 26–Oct. 20) has Stratton 58.5% to Tracy's 41.5%; Public Policy Polling (Sept. 30–Oct. 1) has her 49% to 36%. The money: through September 30 FEC reports, Stratton raised $7.09 million and held $1.65 million cash on hand; Tracy raised $4.15 million — of which roughly $3.5 million is money he loaned his own campaign — and held $1.15 million.

Juliana Stratton (Democratic)

Her record: Stratton has been lieutenant governor of Illinois since 2019, elected on the Pritzker ticket in 2018 — the first African American woman to hold the office. Before that she served two years as a state representative from Chicago's 5th District. She is a lawyer, a mediator, and a former administrative law judge. As lieutenant governor she is associated with the Birth Equity Initiative — coverage of midwives, doulas, and lactation consultants, aimed at Black maternal health — per her campaign as reported by WCIA. One honest boundary: her tenure is on a joint ticket, and the sources gathered document the initiative and her campaign positions far better than any detailed executive record attributable to her office alone.

Her platform, in her own words at the race's only joint forum (WTTW, October 20, 2026): she supports Medicare for All; a $25-an-hour federal minimum wage; a middle-class tax cut funded by higher taxes on households earning over $1 million; she refuses corporate PAC money; and she pledged to serve as a check on President Trump and to vote against additional federal funds for the Iran war. Her reported endorsements include Barack Obama and End Citizens United.

Pros: She beat two sitting congressmen in a primary — that is a real political achievement, not an appointment. Seven years as a statewide elected official. A maternal-health initiative with her name on it. In a state her party dominates, she is the dominant party's legitimately chosen candidate.

Cons: Read the platform as a program, because it is one: single-payer health care, a $25 federal wage floor — more than triple the current federal minimum — and tax increases on high earners to fund the rest. That is not a moderation platform with a flaw in it; it is the progressive program, complete.

The flaw, plainly: Stratton does not pretend to be a Manchin or a Fetterman, and we will not pretend it for her. There is no record here of breaking with her party on the things that matter — there is a record of rising through it, on its program, with its program as her platform. In the Senate, her organizing vote is the majority, and the majority is confirmations. The flaw is not competence. It is that the competence serves the other side's values, stated plainly and without apology.

Don Tracy (Republican)

His record: Tracy is an attorney — Senior Counsel at Brown, Hay & Stephens in Springfield — born in Urbana and raised in Mt. Sterling. He chaired the Illinois Republican Party from 2021 to 2024 and previously chaired the Illinois Gaming Board. The Chicago Tribune has described him as "a onetime Democrat." He previously ran unsuccessfully for state senate and for lieutenant governor, by his own account.

What he does not have: a voting record. Tracy has never held elected public office. Under our rules that makes him unproven — a watch-closely posture, never a demerit and never a reason by itself to withhold an endorsement. There are no roll calls to examine, and we say so rather than inventing a record from his résumés.

His campaign, sourced: He has loaned his campaign $3.5 million — the bulk of his reported receipts — which is either commitment or a bought ballot line, depending on the reader; the fact itself is FEC-reported. He has pointedly not sought President Trump's endorsement: "I'm seeking the endorsement of the Illinois people." At the WTTW forum — the pair's only joint appearance — he largely defended Trump's positions, called the Iran-war gas-price rise a "temporary spike," attacked Stratton as a Democratic socialist, and described himself as a pragmatic conservative focused on the cost of living.

Pros: A party chairman who rebuilt nothing into something has at least run an organization; the Gaming Board chairmanship is regulatory governing experience, if not elected office. Declining to chase a presidential endorsement while defending the president's positions is a distinction Illinois Republicans rarely draw, and it suggests a man who would rather lose his way than win borrowed. Self-funding means no donor owns the vote.

Cons: Unproven is unproven: no voter has ever hired him for anything, and his two earlier runs for office both lost. Self-funding at $3.5 million also means the campaign's viability is one man's checkbook — the accountability runs to himself. "Pragmatic conservative" is a self-description, not a record.

The flaw, plainly: Tracy's flaw is a blank page where a record should be. Our doctrine prices that correctly: it is not a proven failure, it is an absence — and an absence is weighed against the opponent's presence: a complete progressive program with a majority-organizing vote attached. A blank page can be watched. A program cannot be unwritten.

Also on the ballot: Whitfield Harrington Jr., American Center Party. He was excluded from the WTTW forum for polling under the station's 15% threshold. Beyond ballot qualification, our researchers found no sourced platform, biography, or prior record — we report the gap rather than fill it.

OUR CALL

LiberalMind endorses Don Tracy — as unproven, and on watch.

We have made this call before, in Arizona's First District, and the rule is the same: a conservative candidate who has never held the office is endorsed on his stated alignment and watched on his record-to-come; unproven is never scored as a flaw. Tracy's alignment is documented where documentation exists — party chairmanship, a regulatory chairmanship, a forum performance defending conservative positions on cost of living and the war — and his stated conservatism is pragmatic rather than performative. The alternative is not a moderate Democrat with a flaw; it is Medicare for All, a $25 wage floor, and a millionaire-tax funding scheme, carried by a loyal organizing vote in a Senate where that vote is the majority. The margin in this race is not close and we do not pretend otherwise — endorsements are about who should hold the seat, not who will. Tracy should. He will be watched like a hawk, and this page will say so again if the record he builds betrays the one he promised.

For the complete Election 2026 breakdown — every race, claim by claim — see the full coverage on our website.

Vote early. Research your candidates. Choose the best moderates, whatever their party — no extremism from either side. And encourage your friends and family to do the same.

Sources

Election result — November 4, 2026

Winner: Juliana Stratton (Democratic) — called by the Associated Press. This result was appended on November 4, 2026 (results wave 1); the original article above is unchanged, exactly as published before Election Day.

AI-assisted article — but the sources are human, and the facts are very real.

← Back to the Election Series