← Election Series · All senate races

Our verdict

LiberalMind endorses Kurt Alme

Election Day is November 3. This Class 2 seat came open in the most unusual way in America this year: the incumbent filed for re-election, then quit minutes before the deadline and handed the race to his chosen successor. Four candidates are on the ballot. This is the whole race — the records, the switch, the worst claims against each candidate, and what the sources actually show. Read the research, and decide.

How Montana got here

Senator Steve Daines had filed for a third term. On March 4, 2026, minutes before the candidate filing deadline, he withdrew. Montana Public Radio's report that day: "Sen. Steve Daines is retiring and withdrawing his reelection bid. He anointed the state's U.S. Attorney to take his place in the election." Daines endorsed Kurt Alme the same day; Alme filed shortly before the deadline; President Trump, per the Associated Press, "almost immediately endorsed" Alme and praised Daines for "pass[ing] the torch." Cook Political Report's summary calls it what it was: "National Republicans pulled a last minute switcheroo at the filing deadline." Sabato's Crystal Ball analyzed the consequence: the move "effectively allowed Daines to pick his successor, preventing other Republicans in a GOP-heavy state from seeking the nomination." (Reports differ by a few minutes on the exact sequence of the two filings; the core sequence — both actions on March 4, minutes before the deadline — is consistent across AP, MTPR, Cook, and Sabato.) Let this be unambiguous, because stale coverage is everywhere: Steve Daines is not a candidate in this race. He retired.

The primaries followed on June 2. Per the Secretary of State's certified canvass, Alme won the Republican primary with 76.1% (128,716 votes). Alani Bankhead won the five-way Democratic primary with 43.6% (48,772), defeating former state lawmaker Reilly Neill by ten points. Seth Bodnar, an independent, qualified by petition. Kyle Austin won the Libertarian primary narrowly. The four-name general-election roster — Alme (R), Bankhead (D), Bodnar (I), Austin (L) — is confirmed by Ballotpedia News, by Montana Public Radio's October 12 all-candidate debate coverage, and by a voter guide built from Cascade County's publication of the Secretary of State's general-election certification.

The raters: Cook says Solid R; Inside Elections says Solid R. Sabato's Crystal Ball requires honesty about a conflict: its own March 2026 analysis moved the race from Safe Republican to Likely Republican, writing that "Daines's late retirement, paired with Bodnar's candidacy, makes this race at least a little more interesting… Republicans are still clearly favored to hold the seat"; a later predictions compilation lists the Crystal Ball back at Safe R as of October 14, while another compilation still lists Likely R. We print the March move from the Crystal Ball itself and note that its current label could not be cleanly resolved from the sources in this pass. On money: fundraising figures for this race circulate with conflicting as-of dates and were not reconciled against FEC filings in this pass, so — as with the Louisiana cash-on-hand figure earlier in this series — we do not print totals we cannot stand behind.

Kurt Alme (Republican)

His record — documented by the Justice Department, not just the campaign: Alme was an Assistant U.S. Attorney in Montana from 2003 to 2010, focusing on financial investigations — white-collar, government-program, bankruptcy fraud, money laundering, tax evasion — and First Assistant U.S. Attorney from 2006 to 2010. He was Director of the Montana Department of Revenue under Governor Judy Martz. He was President and General Counsel of the Yellowstone Boys and Girls Ranch Foundation. In September 2017 he was unanimously confirmed as Montana's U.S. Attorney — recommended by Senator Daines, nominated by President Trump — and served until December 2020, chairing the DOJ's Missing and Murdered Indigenous Persons working group. He then served as State Budget Director for Governor Greg Gianforte. In 2025 he returned as interim U.S. Attorney (sworn in March 17, 2025, appointed by Attorney General Pam Bondi), and his confirmation for a second term was announced by Senators Daines and Sheehy on October 7, 2025. His biography: born in Great Falls, raised in Miles City, bachelor's in business from the University of Colorado summa cum laude, Harvard Law cum laude, Harry S. Truman Scholar, clerk to a federal judge, partner at Crowley Fleck.

His self-description (Montana Kaimin voter guide): "I have a proven record of cutting taxes, balancing budgets, paying off debt and locking up violent criminals" — the guide notes his revenue-director role in the 2003 tax changes that lowered Montana's top individual rate from 11% to 6.9%, and his statement that as U.S. Attorney his office prosecuted more than 400 defendants each year.

His positions, as documented in the October debates: On Social Security: "I will never support a cut in benefits for seniors"; he would support the Social Security deduction in the Working Family Tax Cuts Act, and start with stopping fraud. On fiscal discipline: "As senator, I'll bring a bill that says if Congress can't balance the budget, Congress doesn't get paid" — plus pledged term limits, a ban on individual stock trading by members of Congress, and a ban on members becoming lobbyists. He has largely supported President Trump's tariffs and border policies. On China: he calls it the nation's largest geopolitical enemy, says America must decouple from China in national-security supply lines — and also says Montana producers must keep access to China for beef, barley, wheat, and pulse crops. His entry statement, as reported at filing: he was running "to help President Trump put America First." One gap, stated: no detailed Alme campaign issues page was captured in this pass; his platform here rests on debate reporting and voter guides.

Pros: The deepest documented résumé in the race — two decades of prosecution, tax administration, and budget management, verified by the Justice Department's own biography. The 2003 tax-cut record is a record, not a promise. His fiscal pledges are specific enough to be graded later.

Cons: The origin. Everything above is true, and it is also true that he did not win an open field — the field was never allowed to form. The incumbent's last-minute withdrawal, a same-day anointment, and an immediate presidential endorsement arranged the succession before any other Montana Republican could file. That is a process flaw about how he got the nomination, and voters are entitled to hold it against the arrangement even while crediting the man.

The flaw, plainly: Alme's flaw is the switch itself. His record in office is proven and in-tent; how he came to be the nominee was a succession, not a contest. We price it as what it is — a real democratic-process demerit attached to a genuinely qualified candidate — and we note it is the only serious mark in his file.

Alani Bankhead (Democratic)

Her biography — the campaign's claims, and what independent reporting corroborates: Her campaign site's headline: "Retired Air Force lieutenant colonel and federal agent. She hunted terror networks, spies and child predators. Now she's Montana's Democratic nominee for U.S. Senate." The site describes 21 years in the Air Force, leading a counterintelligence task force that caught spies, directing more than 180 agents across eight countries, and building coalitions against child predators. Independent reporting corroborates the core: she is described as a "retired Air Force lieutenant colonel and leadership coach from Helena." Montana Public Radio adds that she spent four years on Hawaii's Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force, and at the October 11 debate she said she "rewrote the policy pivoting our war fighters and counterintelligence away from the global war on terror to the 'great power competition.'" The more granular claims — the task force, the 180 agents — are sourced to her own site and are presented here as her account. No prior elected office for Bankhead was identified in the sources in this pass; she is unproven in electoral service.

Her platform: She runs on universal health care and lifting the Social Security payroll tax cap — at the debate, removing the cap, she said, would fund Social Security in perpetuity, with the wealthy paying "their fair share." In an MTPR interview: "what we have to do is we need to ensure that the wealthy and the billionaire class are paying their fair share. And to me, that means instituting a wealth tax." She takes zero corporate PAC money and backs I-194, the Montana Plan to end dark money. MTPR's characterization of the race: both Bankhead and Bodnar support higher taxes on wealthier Americans and oppose Trump's immigration crackdown, tariffs, and the Iran war.

The party split — documented, not alleged: On July 8, seventeen Democratic state legislators wrote to Bankhead and Bodnar urging them to decide which one would end their campaign. The August 10 withdrawal deadline passed with both on the ballot. On October 12, Montana Democratic Party Chair Shannon O'Brien resigned and endorsed Bodnar over her own party's nominee. Bankhead's response: "Good riddance. She's been working against me since day one." Asked earlier whether she would drop out for Bodnar, she had said he was "absolutely the last person on the face of this earth I would ever drop out of this race for" and, to Montana Free Press, "not only no, but hell no."

Pros: A national-security biography — counterintelligence, task-force work against child predators — that is more Senate-relevant than most résumés in either party this cycle, with the core of it independently corroborated. She won a five-way primary while her own establishment drifted toward the independent, which took some spine.

Cons: The program: universal health care and a wealth tax are the left program, stated plainly. She has never held elected office. And her coalition is fractured by fact — when your own state party chair resigns in October to endorse the independent, "the party is divided" is not an attack line, it is a news report.

The flaw, plainly: Bankhead is a program candidate — wealth tax, universal health care — who is unproven in office and whose party is visibly splitting under her. Her organizing vote, if she ever cast it, would be a reliable one for that program. That is the candidacy, priced whole.

Seth Bodnar (Independent)

His biography: President of the University of Montana from 2018 until January 2026 — his resignation was announced January 21, 2026, and he launched this campaign in March. His campaign biography: graduated first in his class at West Point, Rhodes Scholar at Oxford, deployed to Iraq as an infantry officer, served as a Green Beret, and later was General Electric's first chief digital officer. The AP's launch report corroborates the spine: "graduated first in his class from West Point and served in the Army special forces before working as an executive at GE Transportation." His claims about his UM tenure — turned-around enrollment, stabilized finances, record graduation rates, doubled research — are his campaign's account, attributed as such. He qualified for the ballot with nearly 30,000 signatures from 52 of Montana's 56 counties, more than twice the requirement (the campaign and AP differ slightly on the exact threshold; both agree he submitted well above it).

The caucus pledge: Bodnar says if elected he "will not caucus with Democrats or Republicans, remaining independent" (AP, October 23, 2026). His platform: "independence, affordability and fighting corruption" — specifically, per an interview summary, banning congressional insider trading, lifetime lobbying restrictions for former members, an enforceable ethics code for the Supreme Court, term and age limits, and overturning Citizens United.

His endorsements: Former Democratic Senators Max Baucus and Jon Tester, former Governor Steve Bullock (D), former Governor Marc Racicot (R), the Montana AFL-CIO, Montana Conservation Voters, VoteVets — and, in October, Pete Buttigieg. Plus, by resignation, the Montana Democratic Party's own chair.

The record challenge, with his answer: Bankhead called on Bodnar to drop out, citing what she described as "a pattern dismissing and discriminating against women and allowing a culture of discrimination" during his UM presidency, pointing to a gender-discrimination lawsuit. A fuller interview account: 18 female employees brought a sex-discrimination lawsuit against the Montana University System, including allegations about culture and leadership at UM; the university settled; Bodnar disputed creating a "boys' club," pointed to women hired and promoted under him, and said there was no finding of wrongdoing on his part. His campaign's response to Bankhead: Bodnar took discrimination claims seriously, and "Seth is getting attacked from the left and the right because he will never pay allegiance to Party bosses or political elites." The lawsuit existed; it settled; no finding against Bodnar is documented in the sources in this pass. We report exactly that much.

His debate record: At the October 11 debate, Bodnar agreed with Bankhead on lifting the Social Security cap and having wealthier Americans contribute more, and criticized Alme over "tax giveaways" during Alme's tenure as Governor Gianforte's budget director (MTPR's summary).

Pros: The strongest independent biography in any Senate race this cycle, a petition operation that proved real organization, cross-party endorsements that include a Republican former governor, and an explicit, quotable no-caucus pledge.

Cons: Look at the coalition. Baucus, Tester, Bullock, the AFL-CIO, Buttigieg, and the Democratic chair who quit her job to back him — against one Republican former governor. On the one fiscal question put to all four candidates side by side, he stood with the Democrat. A no-caucus pledge tells you where he won't sit; his endorsements tell you whose calls get returned.

The flaw, plainly: The same flaw as Nebraska's independent race, in a stronger candidate: independence as branding, coalition as fact. An uncommitted organizing vote in a Senate decided by a handful of votes is a risk the majority cannot be asked to underwrite — and this one's coalition has already told you which side underwrites him.

Kyle Austin (Libertarian)

Austin is a Billings pharmacist — a former Republican who ran in the Republican primaries for Montana's 2nd congressional district in 2022 and 2024 before running as a Libertarian for Senate; a KTVQ profile summary says he switched parties over division and name-calling among Republicans. He won the Libertarian primary narrowly — and the state Libertarian Party disavowed him, having endorsed his opponent at its April convention as more ideologically aligned. At the October 11 debate he likened Social Security to "an old farm engine that needs an overhaul" and called for letting recipients manage their own funds; he vowed an America First agenda including domestic rare-earth mining and processing. He calls himself the only "real conservative" in the race and runs on a health-care agenda he calls "Healthcare 2.0" — which, per MTPR, would consolidate American health care under one system and has released no written details. A candidate disavowed by his own party, running on an unwritten health plan, is a protest vehicle, and we treat him as one.

One more name: A registered write-in candidacy (Jami Dee Woodman) appears in a single non-official voter summary. It is not confirmed against Secretary of State records in this pass, and we do not list her as a ballot candidate.

OUR CALL

LiberalMind endorses Kurt Alme.

Alme is the only candidate in this race with a proven, documented, in-service record that matches our values: a prosecutor who locked up criminals, a revenue director who worked on the tax cuts that dropped Montana's top rate from 11% to 6.9%, a budget director, twice the state's U.S. Attorney. His flaw is the succession — arranged, not contested — and it is priced above at full weight; it is a flaw about how he got the nomination, not about what he has done with every office he has actually held. The alternatives do not survive the criteria. Bankhead carries the left program (wealth tax, universal health care) as an unproven candidate whose own party chair resigned to oppose her. Bodnar is the strongest independent in America this year, and his pledge is explicit — but his coalition is the Democratic establishment minus its nominee, his one side-by-side fiscal answer matched the Democrat's, and caucus math in the Senate prices an uncommitted organizing vote as a loss whether or not the candidate intends it as one. Montana should send the prosecutor. It should also remember how he got the job — and the next Republican who wants this seat should have to win it in the open.

For the complete Election 2026 breakdown — every race, claim by claim — see the full coverage on our website.

Vote early. Research your candidates. Choose the best moderates, whatever their party — no extremism from either side. And encourage your friends and family to do the same.

Sources

Election result — November 4, 2026

Winner: Kurt Alme (Republican) — called by the Associated Press. This result was appended on November 4, 2026 (results wave 1); the original article above is unchanged, exactly as published before Election Day.

AI-assisted article — but the sources are human, and the facts are very real.

← Back to the Election Series