← Election Series · State Legislature coverage · Arizona districts
Endorses Werner
The district
Legislative District 4 covers Paradise Valley and North Scottsdale. Its partisan baseline is Republican +3.5 in the 2024 presidential vote — one of the most competitive districts in Arizona, where both parties have a realistic path in every race. Three seats are at stake: one state Senate seat and two state House seats on a vote-for-two ballot.
The Senate incumbent, Carine Werner, won the seat in 2024. The House incumbents, Matt Gress and Pamela Carter, are both Republicans seeking re-election.
The Senate race
Carine Werner (R), incumbent. Werner won this seat in 2024 and now defends it in a district that splits nearly evenly. Winning a marginal seat and holding it are the record the compiled file establishes.
Pros: A proven winner in an R+3.5 district — the hardest kind of seat to take and keep — holding a Senate seat where the organizing vote carries the heaviest weight in our pricing. Cons: No proven in-service flaw was located in the compiled record at this sourcing depth. The flaw, plainly: None proven was located in the compiled record.
Aaron Lieberman (D). Lieberman is a former state representative who resigned in 2021 to run for governor. His best honest case is real: he has legislative experience, he has run statewide, and in a district this close, a candidate of his profile is a serious contender — this is no token challenge.
Pros: A former state representative with prior legislative service and a statewide campaign behind him; the strongest kind of challenger a marginal district produces. Cons: No Manchin-test break was located — no documented in-service fight against his own party toward our values. In the Senate, where a Democrat's organizing vote controls confirmations and compounds through the judicial pipeline, a party-line record does not earn the exception. The flaw, plainly: Enabler class, not extremist — experienced, but a party-line Democrat in the chamber where that is priced heaviest.
The House race
Matt Gress (R), incumbent, led the Republican primary with 20,955 votes (45.31%), and Pamela Carter (R), incumbent, was renominated with 15,572 votes (33.67%). The Democratic nominees are Karen Gresham, who led her primary with 20,079 votes (51.70%), and Tammy Caputi, with 18,762 votes (48.30%) — primary totals showing how live this district is on both sides.
The Democratic nominees' best honest case: in an R+3.5 district, the House is where a flip is most plausible, and House caucus math is lighter — a stalled House is not a lost House when the Senate stays in our hands. That is a fair argument, and we state it plainly. It does not carry the call against two incumbent Republicans with no proven flaw located, but it is why this race is closer in our pricing than the Senate race.
Pros: Gress and Carter — renominated incumbents. Gresham and Caputi — a full, strongly voted Democratic slate in a genuinely competitive district. Cons: Gresham and Caputi — party-line Democrats; no Manchin-test break was located for either. The flaw, plainly: None proven was located for Gress or Carter; for the Democratic nominees, enabler class, not extremist.
OUR CALL
Senate — We endorse Carine Werner. Lieberman is a serious challenger and we steelman him as one — but seriousness is not a Manchin-test break, and Senate caucus math is the heaviest price in our criteria.
House — We endorse Matt Gress and Pamela Carter. Both are renominated incumbents with no proven flaw located. The lighter House caucus math narrows the margin of this reasoning; it does not reverse it.
For the complete Election 2026 breakdown — every race, claim by claim — see the full coverage on our website.
Vote early. Research your candidates. Choose the best moderates, whatever their party — no extremism from either side. And encourage your friends and family to do the same.
Sources
- Wikipedia, "2026 Arizona Senate election" and "2026 Arizona House of Representatives election" (compiling Arizona Secretary of State primary results, July 21, 2026, and SeeTheMoney campaign-finance reports as of March 2026) — rosters, primary vote totals and percentages, incumbency, Werner's 2024 win, Lieberman's biography as compiled, and the 2024 presidential baseline (Dave's Redistricting via Wikipedia)
- Record gaps: no detailed legislative voting records or campaign-finance figures for the nominees in this district were verified at this sourcing depth
- Standing check: no pedophile-association material meeting the proven standard was located for any candidate on this ballot
Result pending. No verified call (Associated Press or official) as of November 4, 2026. This page will be updated when the race is called or certified. The original article above is unchanged.
AI-assisted article — but the sources are human, and the facts are very real.
← All Arizona state-legislative districts · Full state-legislative enumeration