← Election Series · All statewide races

Our verdict

LiberalMind endorses Don Wagner

Election Day is November 3 — and this race is being fought, mid-election, in federal court. Shirley Weber (D), Secretary of State since 2021, refused a U.S. Department of Justice demand in October to review a federal thumb drive of suspected noncitizen voters and set ballots aside within 48 hours; DOJ sued two days later. Her Republican challenger, Orange County Supervisor Don Wagner, is himself a plaintiff in a separate federal suit alleging 873,092 inactive registrations have sat on California's rolls through at least three federal elections — allegations in a complaint, not adjudicated. Weber led the primary 54.2% to 41.4%. No ratings or public polling were located, and no verified campaign-money figures were located for either campaign in this research. LiberalMind endorses Don Wagner. Read the records, and see why.

The race

Weber led the June 2, 2026 top-two primary with 54.2% (2,567,451 votes) in count-stage Secretary of State returns; Wagner was second at 41.4% (1,962,410 votes); both advanced. Wagner frames the structural math himself: "Republicans fall out of bed and get 40% on the statewide ballot. Closing the gap to 51%… is a challenge" (Orange County Register interview). Weber won this office in 2022 with 60%.

Shirley Weber (Democratic) — the incumbent

Background and service: Secretary of State since 2021 (appointed, then elected 2022); previously a professor and a four-term assemblymember. As Secretary of State she made universal vote-by-mail permanent.

The two live fights on her 2026 record, stated at their exact strength: (1) She refused the DOJ demand — delivered October 13, 2026 — to review a federal thumb drive of suspected noncitizen voters within 48 hours and set ballots aside mid-election; DOJ sued two days later. (2) She is the named defendant in Wagner et al. v. Weber, a June 2026 federal NVRA lawsuit alleging 873,092 inactive registrations have remained on the rolls through at least three federal elections. That figure is an allegation in a complaint, sourced to the plaintiff-side Judicial Watch release; it is not adjudicated, and we print it at exactly that strength — no more.

Pros: Five years administering California elections, a professor's and legislator's résumé before it, and a decisive posture under federal pressure — she did not hand a mid-election ballot review to a 48-hour federal deadline.

Cons: Her tenure's direction is expansion without a sourced counterweight: universal mail voting made permanent on her watch, and a rolls-maintenance fight she is litigating as a defendant rather than answering with a published cleanup. No in-service break with her party on election administration — or on our values generally — was located. No Manchin-test material.

The flaw, plainly: Classification, again, not proven conduct: the 873,092 figure is an unadjudicated allegation and we price it as one — it is not her proven flaw. Her proven record is party-standard election administration with no located break; that is the enabler classification, not extremism.

Don Wagner (Republican) — the challenger

Background and service: Orange County supervisor and board chairman; previously mayor of Irvine and an assemblymember. He is a plaintiff in the NVRA suit against Weber described above, brought with the American Independent Party.

His program: Voter ID — he supports Proposition 39, the 2026 voter-ID measure — cleaning the voter rolls, and faster counting.

Pros: A proven record across three levels of the job's pipeline: city mayor, state legislator, and chairman of the board of one of California's largest counties. His program is specific to the office's core duties — who is on the rolls, how identity is checked, how fast results come — and his rolls position was taken in court, in service, before it was a campaign line.

Cons: He starts thirteen points behind in the only numbers that exist and says himself that closing to 51% is the challenge. His signature evidentiary claim, the 873,092 inactive registrations, is his own lawsuit's allegation — unadjudicated, and priced that way in this piece.

The flaw, plainly: No flaw proven in service was sourced against him in this research. His court claim may yet be proven or fail; an allegation he filed is not a proven flaw in either direction.

OUR CALL

LiberalMind endorses Don Wagner.

Secretary of State is the office where our values meet the mechanics: rolls that can be audited, identity that can be checked, counts that arrive on time. Weber's in-service record is her party's standard program — permanent universal mail voting, resistance to a federal noncitizen review, and no located break with that program in five years — so the Manchin exception is not earned. Wagner is proven in service at the city, legislative and county levels, and his program — voter ID under Proposition 39, rolls cleanup, faster counting — is aimed at exactly those mechanics. We print his lawsuit's central number as the unadjudicated allegation it is; the endorsement does not need it to be more than that, because the call rests on the two records, not on the complaint.

For the complete Election 2026 breakdown — every race, claim by claim — see the full coverage on our website.

Vote early. Research your candidates. Choose the best moderates, whatever their party — no extremism from either side. And encourage your friends and family to do the same.

Sources

Election result — November 4, 2026

Winner: Shirley Weber (Democratic) — called by the Associated Press. This result was appended on November 4, 2026 (results wave 1); the original article above is unchanged, exactly as published before Election Day.

AI-assisted article — but the sources are human, and the facts are very real.

← Back to the Election Series