← Election Series · All statewide races

Our verdict

LiberalMind endorses James Uthmeier

Election Day is November 3. James Uthmeier was appointed Florida's attorney general in February 2025, after Ashley Moody resigned to take a U.S. Senate seat, and he has never won this office at an election. His Democratic challenger, José Javier Rodríguez, is a former state senator who lost his seat in 2020 by 32 votes in a race with a documented ghost candidate. Between them sits the Hope Florida grand-jury report — published by CBS News Miami on August 26, ordered expunged by an appeals court on October 7, after the grand jury itself reported insufficient evidence to charge anyone — and we print that sequence whole, at exactly its procedural status, because it is an expunged, unadjudicated matter and not a finding of guilt. The polls conflict and we print both. LiberalMind endorses James Uthmeier. Read the research, and see why.

The race

Both nominees were unopposed in their August 18, 2026 primaries and advanced directly to November. A filed Republican challenger, interim Punta Gorda city attorney Steven Leskovich, failed to qualify — filed is not on-ballot. The confirmed general-election roster, per the Volusia/Flagler official-ballot compilation in the Daytona Beach News-Journal, BallotReady, and Ballotpedia: James Uthmeier (Republican), incumbent by appointment, vs. José Javier Rodríguez (Democratic). No third-party, no-party-affiliation, or qualified write-in candidate appears in any ballot compilation consulted. Republicans have held this office since Bob Butterworth left it in 2002.

The polls conflict, and we print them named, dated, and never averaged. St. Pete Polls, October 5–7, 2026, 836 likely voters, ±3.4: Uthmeier 45%, Rodríguez 43%. A James Madison Institute poll (October 2026, likely voters): Uthmeier 50%, Rodríguez 40%. A mid-September St. Pete Polls survey had it 43–42. A July 2026 Change Research poll, commissioned by a Democratic-aligned group and labeled as such, was tied 43–43. No Cook/Sabato/Inside Elections rating exists for this race.

The money (named source, never averaged): Uthmeier raised more than $11.6 million across his campaign and his committee, Friends of James Uthmeier, with more than $9.5 million on hand (Florida Politics, October 2026); Ike and Laura Perlmutter gave $500,000 combined to his committee in one fall week. Rodríguez raised roughly $2.8 million and spent nearly $1.7 million (Florida Politics, October 2026). The Democratic Attorneys General Association is reported to be backing Rodríguez with $5 million — a single-compilation figure, not independently re-sourced in this research, printed at that strength.

James Uthmeier (Republican) — the incumbent by appointment

Background and service: Gov. Ron DeSantis's chief of staff (2021–2025) before the appointment; previously counsel to Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross and counsel to Donald Trump's 2016 campaign. He runs with Trump's endorsement, backed by 51 county sheriffs, the Republican Party of Florida, Club for Growth, and RAGA. His status, priced precisely: unproven at the ballot box for this office — never elected to it — and proven as the governor's chief of staff and, since February 2025, in the office itself.

In office: He spearheaded the Everglades immigration detention facility nicknamed "Alligator Alcatraz" — a CBS News investigation put its cost at about $1.2 billion, roughly 20 times the per-person cost of most other U.S. detention facilities; the facility has since been shuttered. Our framing rule is standing and we apply it here: we back ICE the agency and its job, always; immigration enforcement is the law being enforced, never a candidate's stain. The facility's cost figure is attributed reporting about a state spend, printed as such — a fiscal question, not an enforcement demerit. He also filed a November 2025 lawsuit accusing Planned Parenthood of racketeering over statements that medication-abortion drugs are "safer than Tylenol." A transparency item, printed at its weight: as of mid-October 2026 his office had not published an updated "Government in the Sunshine" manual; open-government advocates criticized the lapse, and Rodríguez pledged to keep publishing it.

Hope Florida — the whole sequence, at its exact status: A Leon County grand jury's 116-page presentment, filed under seal on January 28, 2026, examined the $10 million that Centene's roughly $67 million Medicaid settlement sent to the Hope Florida Foundation — money the Foundation granted, $5 million each, to two nonprofits that in turn sent a combined $8.5 million to Keep Florida Clean, the committee against the 2024 recreational-marijuana amendment, which Uthmeier chaired as the governor's chief of staff. The grand jury called the $10 million "misappropriated," part of a scheme to fund political activities, and named Uthmeier as involved in directing it — and reported insufficient evidence to indict anyone. The presentment stayed sealed until CBS News Miami published it in full on August 26, 2026. On September 3, House Democratic Leader Fentrice Driskell called for a special session to consider impeaching Uthmeier and for a House investigation. Rodríguez called Uthmeier, in his own words, "My opponent is a criminal," and called on him to resign — an opponent's characterization, attributed. Uthmeier's denial is on the record in his own words: "nobody did anything wrong here" — and he called the grand jury "weaponized." On October 7, 2026, the First District Court of Appeal ordered the presentment expunged in full, holding that the settlement arrangement was legal, that the $10 million was never public money, and that a grand jury may not publicly condemn people it does not indict; on October 16 the same court refused to ban publication of the report's findings, which remain in circulation in campaign ads. We print it at exactly that status: an expunged grand-jury report is an unadjudicated matter, not a finding of guilt. Under our doctrine an unproven accusation never disqualifies — and an expunged report with no charges filed is the definition of unproven. It is the heaviest unresolved item in his file, and it stays in the file, labeled, forever; it does not become a verdict here.

Pros: Trump's endorsement, 51 sheriffs, his party's full apparatus. A proven record as the state's chief executive's chief of staff and twenty months running this office. A money advantage of roughly four to one before any outside Democratic spending.

Cons: Never elected to anything — this is his first general election for the office he holds. The Hope Florida matter hangs over the race as an expunged, uncharged, unresolved public record. The Sunshine-manual lapse is a small, documented transparency failure in the office charged with open government.

The flaw, plainly: An unresolved, unadjudicated controversy at the center of his short tenure — priced as unproven, because that is what the procedural record says it is — plus a minor transparency lapse that is proven because it is documented.

José Javier Rodríguez (Democratic) — the challenger

Background and service: A Miami workers'-rights attorney. Florida House 2012–2016, Florida Senate 2016–2020. In 2020 he lost his Senate re-election by 32 votes in a race in which former state Sen. Frank Artiles recruited and funded a same-surname "ghost" spoiler candidate — a documented episode from the public record, and we print it as the context it is: his one electoral loss came in a race a court-documented scheme helped decide. In the Biden administration he served as Assistant Secretary of Labor for Employment and Training; his Senate confirmation came only in March 2024, on a narrow 50–48 vote, after an earlier failed attempt — Sen. Fetterman was a notable Democratic no, citing inexperience. That confirmation fight is a record fact, not an opponent claim.

His campaign, in his own words: "crime, costs and corruption" — enforce the minimum-wage law against wage theft, take on utilities and insurers, recover "stolen tax dollars."

Pros: A proven legislative record across eight years in both chambers, and a federal executive tenure after it. A genuine grievance from 2020 that is documented, not alleged. A focused campaign frame aimed at wages and costs — kitchen-table ground.

Cons: His record is his party's standard, served under a Democratic administration, with no break from the Democratic program on our values located — the Manchin test looks for proven in-service breaks, and his service shows none. The one Democrat whose judgment on him is in the record at confirmation — Fetterman, a name on our own values-aligned list — voted no on his experience. His "criminal" framing of the Hope Florida report overstates an expunged, uncharged matter, and we have priced that overstatement above.

The flaw, plainly: A party-line record with no Manchin-test item, and an experience question raised on the record by a senator of his own party. No conduct flaw was sourced against him.

OUR CALL

LiberalMind endorses James Uthmeier.

Price the two files as they stand. Uthmeier is the in-tent candidate, proven in executive service and in this office since February 2025, endorsed by the President and 51 of the state's sheriffs. The gravest item against him — Hope Florida — is, on the procedural record, an expunged grand-jury report, an impeachment call from the opposing party's House leader, and no charges filed — the grand jury itself reported insufficient evidence to indict: an unadjudicated matter that our doctrine forbids us to price as guilt, printed whole above so no reader mistakes our call for a cover-up. Rodríguez is a proven legislator running his party's standard program; the Manchin exception requires breaks in service and there are none in his file, and his own confirmation record carries an experience objection from a Democratic senator we count as values-aligned. We endorse Uthmeier — and we flag this call as the borderline one in Florida's three Cabinet races: it turns entirely on holding the Hope Florida matter at its exact procedural status. If charges are ever filed, the pricing changes, and this living article will say so in a dated update.

For the complete Election 2026 breakdown — every race, claim by claim — see the full coverage on our website.

Vote early. Research your candidates. Choose the best moderates, whatever their party — no extremism from either side. And encourage your friends and family to do the same.

Sources

Election result — November 4, 2026

Winner: James Uthmeier (Republican) — called by the Associated Press. This result was appended on November 4, 2026 (results wave 1); the original article above is unchanged, exactly as published before Election Day.

AI-assisted article — but the sources are human, and the facts are very real.

← Back to the Election Series